By Carl Cohen

"No nation . . . shall deny to anybody inside of its jurisdiction the equivalent safeguard of the laws." So says the equivalent defense Clause of the U.S. structure, a record held expensive by means of Carl Cohen, a professor of philosophy and longtime champion of civil liberties who has committed such a lot of his grownup existence to the college of Michigan. So whilst Cohen chanced on, after encountering a few resistance, how his university, in its admirable desire to bring up minority enrollment, used to be really practising a kind of racial discrimination—calling it "affirmative action"—he chanced on himself at odds along with his longtime allies and associates for you to protect the equivalent remedy of the races at his collage. In A clash of Principles Cohen tells the tale of what occurred at Michigan, how racial personal tastes have been devised and applied there, and what used to be at stake within the heated and divisive controversy that ensued. He offers voice to the sensible and infrequently heard liberal argument opposed to affirmative motion in university admission policies.

In the early Seventies, as a member of the Board of administrators of the yank Civil Liberties Union, Cohen vigorously supported courses devised to motivate the recruitment of minorities in schools, and in deepest employment. yet a few of these efforts gave planned choice to blacks and Hispanics looking college admission, and this Cohen well-known as a sort of racism, despite the fact that well-meaning. In his booklet he recounts the fortunes of contested affirmative motion courses as they made their approach during the felony procedure to the ideally suited courtroom, starting with DeFunis v. Odegaard (1974) on the college of Washington legislation tuition, then Bakke v. Regents of the college of California (1978) on the scientific university at the UC Davis campus, and culminating on the college of Michigan within the landmark instances of Grutter v. Bollinger and Gratz v. Bollinger (2003). He recounts his position within the initiation of the Michigan situations, explaining the numerous arguments opposed to racial personal tastes in collage admissions. He provides a principled case for the ensuing modification to the Michigan structure, of which he used to be a admired recommend, which prohibited choice by way of race in public employment and public contracting, in addition to in public education.

An eminently readable own, constantly fair-minded account of the rules and politics that come into play within the struggles over affirmative motion, A clash of Principles is a deeply considerate and thought-provoking contribution to our nationwide dialog approximately race.

Show description

Read or Download A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan PDF

Similar constitutional law books

The Mississippi State Constitution (Oxford Commentaries on the State Constitutions of the United States)

This authoritative reference advisor incorporates a accomplished heritage of Mississippis constitutional advancements over the last a hundred seventy five years and issues to wishes for modern reform. the amount offers the textual content of the structure, together with an article-by-article remark, and makes use of complaints and interpretative critiques over the last century to illustrate adjustments in Mississippis primary legislations.

Right to Information Act 2005 (1)

The booklet pertains to the correct to details in India. an excellent expertise has come after this enactment and the pubic normally became correct wide awake afte the applying of this legislation. The e-book comes in handy for comperative stories universally.

Constitution Making during State Building

How can fragmented, divided societies that aren't instantly appropriate with centralised statehood top comply with nation buildings? This e-book employs either comparative constitutional legislation and comparative politics, because it proposes the assumption of a 'constituent process', wherein public participation in structure making performs a favorable position in country construction.

Tribal Justice: Twenty-Five Years as a Tribal Appellate Justice

Tribal Justice is a e-book that offers an in-depth assessment and survey of tribal appellate courtroom jurisprudence. the actual themes lined comprise enrollment and disenrollment, civil rights, elections and political participation, felony legislations and approach, rights of juveniles, tribal constitutions, and culture and customized.

Extra resources for A Conflict of Principles: The Battle Over Affirmative Action at the University of Michigan

Sample text

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.01 of 5 – based on 25 votes